Winning the War (Part 1): Tell Us Something We Don’t Know!

(Note: This is part 1 of a multi-post series… Part Two can be read by clicking here!)

For the last few days, I’ve been hearing virtually the same thing from everyone with half a brain or half a conscience: why is the U.S. Government bailing out Wall Street while doing nothing to help ordinary Americans.

I’ve heard this from news anchors, and while walking down the street in New York City, reading in a cafe, sitting on the train, and talking to my family. I’ve event heard, on several occasions, people and news anchors directly questioning the very nature of free market economics and capitalism. More importantly, this is a consistent message coming from ordinary people across the political spectrum. I want to draw two points from this.

Tell Us Something We Don’t Know!

Everyone has thought for ages, continues to thinks, and will keep thinking in the future that our world, our economy, our government, and our culture are all utterly corrupt, undemocratic, and unjust. Someone close to me told me last week, flat out: “Brian, it’s the end of the world.” They were referring to the simultaneous bank failures, multiple hurricanes, Midwest floods, and other symptoms of the ongoing climate and economic crises.

Mind you, almost none of these messages are coming from the “American Left”. And for a very good reason: there is no “American Left”. There is no organized force in the United States capable of responding to crises such as these. But I’ll come back to that point in minute.

As I wrote in my last post, both President Bush and Senator McCain have been talking about how market economics are the “best system ever devised” (Bush) and how the “fundamentals of our economy are strong” (McCain). Senator Obama quickly responded that it showed how McCain’s statement was detached from the reality of what’s going on in our country. An organized left, if one actually existed, would have responded slightly differently I think. McCain isn’t detached - at least not on this issue. Neither is President Bush. They both know exactly what they are doing. They know that when the entire population is questioning if capitalism is even a workable system, you have to parrot back: “there is no alternative, stupid”, and “grow up”, “deal with reality”, or more precisely “capitalism is the best system ever devised” (Bush). An organized left would have seen these statements for what they are: apologies and propaganda used to uphold an utterly flawed and profoundly undemocratic economic system which is currently in deeply in crisis.

Even better, the people in this country needed no convincing that capitalism is a garbage system - they already knew it. It wasn’t the left who convinced young people that this system is undemocratic and unjust. Their daily experiences taught them that. Gone are the days when leftists in American have any justification for their belief that we can win Americans to our cause by explaining to them, day after day, why the system is rotten. They know that already. Gone are the days when leftists - both “old” and “new” - have any justification for their argument that we don’t need an inspiring and hopeful vision of the future in order to compel people to action. Barack Obama has a vision for America’s future. John McCain has a vision for America’s future. A developing left needs a vision for America’s future. People are tired of hearing about the problems. They already know what’s wrong. They want to hear about solutions. They want to hear about alternatives. They want to hear about a life after capitalism.

(Read Part Two!)